Three positively charged particles, with charges q1=q, q2=2q, and q3=q (where q>0), are located at the corners of a square with sides of length d. The charge q2 is located diagonally from the remaining (empty) corner.
Find the magnitude of the resultant electric field Enet in the empty corner of the square.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART A:
Below is an incomplete pictorial representation of the situation described in this problem. Complete the sketch by drawing the electric field due to each charge at point P. Make sure that all your vectors have the correct orientation.
The orientation of your vectors will be graded. The length of your vectors will not be graded.
SOLUTION:
Very obvious. The direction of the electric field is the same as the connecting line between the charge and point P
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART B:
Now, consider the resultant electric field Enet at P. With reference to the coordinate system shown in the previous part, which component of Enet, if any, is zero in this problem?
- only the x component
- only the y component
- both the x and y components
- neither the x nor the y component
none of the components is zero, so the last option is correct
neither the x nor the y component
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART C:
Determine the magnitude Enet of the net electric field at point P. Use K for the electrostatic constant.
Express your answer in terms of q, d, and K.
Express your answer in terms of q, d, and K.
SOLUTION:
Using equation (26.1) E = kq/r2, all components of all electric fields can be determined.
the electric field due to q3 at point P is just an x-component of a field...
the distance in consideration is just d, so
E3 = E3x =kq/d2
E3 = E3x =kq/d2
the electric field due to q2 at point P is both an x-component and a y-component of a field...
since the setup is that of a square, the magnitude of the x-component is equal to the magnitude of the y-component.
E2x = E2cos(45) = E2cos(45) = E2⋅1/√2
E2x = E2cos(45) = E2cos(45) = E2⋅1/√2
E2x = kq√2/(2d2)
the y-component is the same but in the y-direction.
Enetx = E3x + E2x
Enetx = E3x + E2x
= kq/d2 + (√2/2)kq/d2
⇒Enetx =(1+√2/2)kq/d2
⇒Enetx =(1+√2/2)kq/d2
the y-magnitude of this net electric field is the same as the x-magnitude, but in the y-direction.
total mag = √(x+y)
& if |x| = |y| ... then total mag = x⋅√2 = y⋅√2
→ Enet = √2⋅(1+√2/2)kq/d2
⇒ Enet =(1+√2)kq/d2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART D:
Intuitively, which of the following would happen to Enet if d became very large?
- A) Enet should reduce to the field of a point charge of magnitude q.
- B) Enet should reduce to the field of a point charge of magnitude 4q.
- C) The larger d becomes, the smaller the magnitude of Enet will be.
- D) The larger d becomes, the greater the magnitude of Enet will be.
Enter the letters of all the correct answers in alphabetical order. Do not use commas. For instance, if you think that A and D are correct, enter AD.
SOLUTION:
NOTE:
Looking at your answer derived in Part C, you should see that the magnitude Enet will decrease as d gets larger, just as you would expect. Your results do make sense! It is interesting to notice that the field will not reduce to that of a point charge (of magnitude 4q) unless the point P is moved farther away from the three charges while they themselves remain at their original positions.